Skip to content
contact@diagtram.com France and international
Response within 48 working hours Public procurement area FR | EN
DiagTraM, governance and steering Book a meeting
Article, Public strategy

The platform state: why public authorities benefit from building foundations rather than doing everything

Perspective, Public-private interplay
PONTPerimeter, Openness
Neutrality, Transfer

The strategic question is not how much State, but where to position the State.

Public strategy is too often confined to a lazy dilemma: either the State does it, or the market does. This opposition is reassuring because it simplifies, but it impoverishes decision-making. The best-performing public organisations, those that create lasting value over twenty years, have grasped a third way. They seek neither to produce everything nor to delegate everything. They build the common foundation on which a multitude of actors, public and private, can build in turn. This article offers a definition, a decision grid and a few practical lessons for thinking about this interplay differently.

Moving beyond the false public versus private debate

Let us begin by defining the subject precisely. By platform state I mean a public authority that concentrates its action not on the direct provision of every service, but on building and governing a common, open and neutral infrastructure that other actors use to create value. This is not privatisation in disguise, because the State retains control of the foundation. Nor is it statism, because the State deliberately refrains from occupying the entire value chain. It is a choice about the level of intervention.

The distinction is fundamental and often misunderstood. The strategic question is not how much State, but where to position the State. A public euro invested in a shared standard does not deliver the same social return as a euro invested in a service that the market would have produced anyway. The first creates the conditions for a multitude of initiatives. The second replaces a single one. Public performance is measured less by the size of the apparatus than by the leverage of its interventions.

A specific example illustrates the principle. In 2026, as its digital programme marked its eleventh anniversary, India had in its UPI payment system an infrastructure that had processed more than 241 billion transactions in a single financial year, recognised by the International Monetary Fund as the largest real-time payment system in the world, and already supported by partnerships with 24 countries (ANI News, 30 June 2026). The State neither nationalised payments nor abandoned them to the market. It laid an open rail, and thousands of private actors ran their trains on it. It is a dated illustration of a timeless principle.

Figure 1Three levels of intervention, a single lever effect
Where to position the StateThe producer State replaces one initiative, the platform state makes a multitude possible, the absent State lets the common good slip away.THE QUESTION IS NOT HOW MUCH STATE, BUT WHERE TO PLACE ITTHE STATE DOES ALLDirect public service1 useReplaces one initiativethe market would have led.STATE LAYS THE BASEOPEN AND NEUTRAL BASEMakes possiblea multitude of initiatives.STATE WITHDRAWSNO COMMON BASErentLets a captivemonopoly settle.A euro put into a shared standard does not yield the same returnas a euro put into a service.The first multiplies initiatives. The second replaces one.
Three levels of intervention, a single lever effect

The PONT grid: four conditions for a foundation that holds

A public foundation only becomes a lever if it meets four conditions. I group them in a grid that I use in diagnostic work, the PONT grid (pont is French for “bridge”), because a good foundation is precisely what connects without confining.

The grid
PONT, four conditions
1
Perimeter
P for Perimeter. The State builds only what the market will not build on its own, for lack of short-term interest or because the good is common by nature. An identity standard, a land registry, a payment rail, a data standard: these are all foundations with low immediate private profitability but a high collective return. The test is simple. If a single private actor can build the infrastructure and make it pay, the State probably need not take it on. If no one will, or if leaving it to the market creates a captive monopoly, a public perimeter is justified.
2
Openness
O for Openness. The foundation must be interoperable and based on shared standards. A closed infrastructure, accessible to only a few actors, reproduces the very rent it claimed to prevent. Openness is what turns public spending into a multiplier, because it greatly increases the number of actors able to build on it.
3
Neutrality
N for Neutrality. The infrastructure must favour no particular user. This is the condition of trust without which no one invests in the foundation. A rail that quietly advantages one operator ceases to be a common good and becomes an instrument of distortion.
4
Transfer
T for Transfer. The State agrees to step aside so that private initiative can create use value, and captures its return through externalities and a broader tax base, not through operating rent. This is the most politically difficult form of restraint, because it means building without occupying, and investing without capturing the return directly.
Figure 2The PONT grid and its breaking points
The PONT gridPerimeter, Openness, Neutrality, Transfer: each condition with its decision test and what happens when it is missing.FOUR CONDITIONS THAT ONLY WORK TOGETHERPPerimeterWHAT TO BUILD?Test: could a single private actorbuild it and make it pay?If not, a public perimeter is justified.OOpennessWHO CAN BUILD ON IT?Test: interoperable, built on sharedstandards, open to all?If not, spending stops being a multiplier.NNeutralityFOR WHOSE BENEFIT?Test: no user is favoured,even discreetly.If not, the rail becomes a tool of distortion.TTransferWHO CREATES USE VALUE?Return captured via externalitiesand a wider tax base, not by rent.Build without occupying: the hardest restraint.A well-defined but closed base fails. An open but non-neutral base is corrupted.
The PONT grid and its breaking points

These four conditions work together. A well-defined but closed foundation fails. An open but non-neutral foundation becomes corrupted. The grid serves to diagnose where a public platform project is at risk of going off the rails.

What the principle changes for local authorities and states

The value of this framework is that it applies well beyond digital and well beyond India. It sheds light on very concrete budgetary trade-offs in resource-constrained contexts.

Take the sustainability of local public finances. In 2026, the French Cour des comptes (Court of Audit) acknowledged that local authorities had contributed €4.3 billion to reducing the public deficit in 2025, while expressing doubts about the trajectory planned for the following year (Cour des comptes, July 2026). In such a context, every public euro counts twice over. The PONT grid becomes an allocation tool. Should funding go to yet another service in direct competition with what already exists, or to a pooled foundation, an open dataset or a shared infrastructure from which twenty actors will benefit? Thinking in terms of foundations redirects spending towards leverage rather than substitution.

The principle also sheds light on regional integration. In 2026, intra-African trade under the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA, ZLECAf in French) was approaching $230 billion, while remaining below 18% of the continent's trade (Africa24, 2026). The gap between the legal framework and the actual market captures the foundation problem exactly. A treaty is a standard, an institutional infrastructure. But without the physical and regulatory rails on top of it (logistics corridors, convergence of standards, trust between administrations), the foundation remains under-used. Laying the track is not enough. The trains must also be able to run.

Figure 3A foundation laid is not enough: the AfCFTA gap
The foundation laid and the foundation used230 billion dollars of intra-African trade, less than 18 per cent of the continent's commerce: the treaty exists, the rails are missing.INTRA-AFRICAN TRADE IN 2026: SHARE OF THE CONTINENT'S TRADE18%MAX.The rest happens off the continentThe legal base exists; the market lags behind.230billion USDof trade under AfCFTALAYING THE TRACK IS NOT ENOUGH: WHAT MUST GO ON TOPTHE TREATY: A STANDARD, AN INSTITUTIONAL INFRASTRUCTURELogistics corridorsThe physical railsStandards convergenceThe regulatory railsMutual trustThe institutional railsLaying the track is not enough. The trains must also be able to run.
A foundation laid is not enough: the AfCFTA gap

Three practical lessons

From this framework, I draw three rules for action that apply to any public organisation or public agency.

First, before launching a project, ask the question of level. Are we seeking to produce a service or to build a foundation? The answer changes everything: how the project is steered, its indicators, its amortisation period. A foundation is judged by the number of actors it enables, a service by its own level of use.

Second, measure leverage, not just direct output. A good indicator for a foundation is not the volume the State processes itself, but the volume that others process thanks to it. This is a complete reversal of the usual reporting logic.

Finally, accept stepping aside as a success, not a retreat. A State that builds a rail and withdraws from operating it has not failed. It has succeeded precisely because others have taken over. This strategic maturity, knowing how to build without seeking to occupy everything, distinguishes administrations that create lasting value from those that merely swell without ever rising.

A rail that others will travel for years to come, or a wall that shelters no one but oneself.

An open conclusion

The opposition between public and private is an intellectual comfort that strategic organisations can do without. The real question is never who should do everything, but who should build what, and at what level.

The platform state is not a turnkey model that can be transplanted from one country to another, since each context has its own priority foundations. It is a discipline of decision-making. Before committing a public resource, it is worth asking whether one is about to build a rail that others will travel for years to come, or a wall that shelters no one but oneself. The answer often redefines the entire strategy.


Sources

DiagTraM newsletter

Receive our next insights

A preview of each new publication, straight to your inbox. Read the full piece on our website.

Unsubscribe in one click. No unsolicited mailings, GDPR compliant.

Written by

Jimmy FÉLIX

Founder, DiagTraM, governance, finance and performance management advisory

All insights
TopicsPublic strategyGovernancePublic finance
Insights

Further reading

Let us take stock of your organisation

A first confidential conversation, with no commitment, to understand your challenges and identify the priority levers for action.