The quality of fiscal adjustment: why the sustainability of public finances cannot be read from the balance
Perspective, Public finance
3filtersto judge the quality
of a fiscal adjustment
The balance measures the scale of the effort. It says almost nothing about its quality.
Reducing a deficit is a relatively easy story to tell. One compares two financial years, observes how the balance has moved and concludes: the effort has been made, or it has not. The problem begins when that figure becomes, on its own, a measure of sound management.
After all, two States can improve their balance by the same proportion while taking radically different paths. The first may eliminate spending that has outlived its purpose, review certain programmes, improve revenue collection and protect its investment. The second may defer the maintenance of its infrastructure, squeeze essential services and halt projects whose benefits will only emerge several years later.
At the end of the financial year, their accounts may nonetheless tell almost the same story. Their future positions, however, will have little left in common.
This is where the real challenge of fiscal consolidation lies: an adjustment should not be judged solely on what it saves today, but on what it still leaves the State able to do tomorrow.
Key idea
The balance measures the scale of the effort. It says almost nothing about its quality.
The balance shows the result. Performance management must look at the path.
The budget balance remains indispensable. It reveals a deficit or a surplus, tracks a financial trajectory and captures part of a State's capacity to honour its commitments. But it essentially answers one question: where have we ended up? It says much less about another question that is nonetheless decisive for performance management: how did we get there?
This distinction is familiar in management control. Two companies may report the same net profit when one has improved its processes and the other has simply stopped investing. In a single accounting snapshot, the difference may seem slight. As soon as one looks across several years, it becomes considerable. The same holds true for public finance.
A saving obtained by eliminating a redundant procedure does not carry the same value as a saving obtained by deferring the maintenance of a road network. A spending cut that stems from better administrative organisation does not have the same consequences as a cut that leads to the loss of skills that are hard to rebuild.
Yet in calculating the balance, these euros look alike. That is precisely what performance management must reintroduce: the nature of the effort behind the figure.
Figure 1Same balance, two futures
A surplus can also conceal a weakness
A budget surplus naturally invites a positive reading. It suggests control, discipline and a return to balance. Yet one must resist a shortcut: not every surplus is necessarily the sign of a financially stronger State. Some savings improve the accounts immediately while shifting the cost to subsequent years.
Infrastructure maintenance provides a simple example. Deferring a repair reduces spending today. In accounting terms, the result improves. But if that decision accelerates the deterioration of the asset, the saving may turn, a few years later, into a far more costly repair. The same logic applies to information systems, administrative skills, certain public investments and prevention policies whose results only materialise over time.
In other words, there is a fundamental difference between reducing a cost and deferring a cost.
Argentina in 2026 offers an interesting case for raising this question without claiming to answer it from the balance alone. Over the first seven months of the year, the national administration posted a cumulative primary surplus of 13.5 trillion pesos. In July, spending had fallen by 14.3% in real terms compared with the same month of the previous year.
These figures reflect a substantial fiscal adjustment. But they immediately raise a second set of questions: which expenditure was squeezed? Which savings will last? Do some cuts affect capacities that will have to be funded again later? This is the point at which the analysis becomes genuinely useful. Before celebrating a surplus, one must understand how it was produced.
Figure 2Dissecting an adjustment
Sustainability is not just about being able to pay
This is where a more demanding definition of fiscal sustainability becomes necessary. Sustainability is generally associated with a State's capacity to finance its commitments and to maintain a debt trajectory consistent with its future resources. That dimension obviously remains central. But from the standpoint of public performance management, it is not enough.
A State can meet a financial constraint while gradually eroding the means that will enable it to fulfil its missions tomorrow. I therefore propose looking at sustainability from a complementary angle: a State's capacity to come through a fiscal effort without destroying the functions on which its future capacity to act will depend.
This definition changes the way a consolidation is read. The question is no longer simply: “How much have we saved?” It becomes: “What have we preserved while saving?”
The difference matters. It requires finances, organisation, public assets, skills and the capacity to deliver services to be examined together. A sustainable State is therefore not simply one that manages to keep its accounts in order. It is one that can keep its accounts in order without gradually draining its capacity to act.
Three questions to judge the quality of an adjustment
To make this approach operational, the analysis can be organised around three questions.
The framework
Three questions to judge the quality of an adjustment
1
Where does the effort really fall?
Not all expenditure has the same effects. Some can be rationalised without lasting harm to public capacity: procedures that have become pointless, organisational duplication, poorly negotiated purchases, programmes whose effectiveness is no longer demonstrated. Other expenditure directly prepares the future: infrastructure, digital transformation, training, maintenance, prevention and investment in people. This does not mean that all spending labelled as investment should be protected. A poorly designed investment remains a misuse of public resources. It simply means that the decision cannot rest solely on the amount that can be cut from the budget.
2
Is the decision reversible?
Some savings are easy to correct. Others far less so. An administration can cut a one-off expense and restore it the following year. It will find it much harder to rebuild a specialist team after several years of departures, to reconstruct severely degraded infrastructure or to quickly recover lost administrative know-how. This question of reversibility is often missing from the budget debate. Yet it should be central: the longer or more costly a capacity is to rebuild, the closer the scrutiny its removal deserves.
3
Can the effort really be sustained?
An adjustment can be technically coherent and politically untenable. If the effort is concentrated on a few groups, a few territories or a few services to the point of provoking constant opposition, it is likely to be short-lived. The next government will reverse the measures, the spending will reappear and the trajectory originally announced will lose its credibility. Sustainability is therefore also social and political. A successful consolidation is not the one that produces the most spectacular effort in the first year. It is the one that can be maintained long enough to deliver its effects.
Figure 3The adjustment quality grid
Good consolidation is not necessarily the one that cuts the most. It is the one that knows what it can reduce without mortgaging what it will still have to achieve.
Credibility comes more from consistency than from severity
There is another temptation in times of financial strain: seeking to reassure through the sheer scale of the gesture. A massive spending cut, a spectacular reform or a particularly ambitious fiscal target can send a powerful signal. But a signal is not yet a trajectory.
Creditors, businesses and citizens gradually learn to tell an announcement from a lasting policy. What builds credibility, therefore, is not only the intensity of the first decision, but the ability to hold a course long enough for it to become predictable.
Monetary policy makes this mechanism easy to observe. In Peru, the policy rate remained at 4.25% for many months in 2025 and 2026. Holding it steady did not mean that no decision was being taken. Quite the opposite: keeping a rate unchanged when conditions are shifting is also a decision, provided it rests on a considered reading of inflation, activity and expectations.
Mauritius offers a different configuration. Having held its policy rate at 4.50% in February 2026, the Bank of Mauritius raised it by 25 basis points in May, to 4.75%, in response to rising inflationary risks.
The decisions differ, but they illustrate the same principle: credibility does not come from standing still. It comes from consistency between a situation, a decision and the announced trajectory. The same is true of fiscal policy. A reasonable, documented multi-year trajectory that is consistently adhered to can generate more confidence than a succession of highly ambitious emergency plans that are later abandoned.
Measuring differently: from the balance to the adjustment dashboard
If the balance is not enough, it should obviously not be discarded. It should be placed in context. A consolidation dashboard could thus track four dimensions simultaneously:
Balance
What financial effort has actually been made?
Composition
Where has the effort fallen?
Capacity
Which functions or assets have been preserved or degraded?
Trajectory
Is the effort repeatable and politically sustainable?
This reading profoundly changes the conversation. A fall in spending is no longer automatically classed as positive. It must be linked to what it changes.
An investment is no longer automatically protected because it bears that label. It must demonstrate its future contribution. A saving is no longer assessed solely on its amount, but also on any deferred cost it may carry.
We thus move from a logic of accounting for the effort to a logic of managing the adjustment.
What public decision-makers can take from this
This approach does not necessarily require the immediate creation of a complex new indicator. It can start with a few simple changes in the way decisions are prepared and evaluated.
First, every significant savings measure should specify not only its expected fiscal yield, but also the nature of the capacity it affects. Second, spending reviews could explicitly incorporate the question of reversibility: if the decision has to be reversed in three years, how much will it cost to rebuild what has been removed?
The multi-year perspective must also be protected. A measure that is advantageous over twelve months can become very costly over five years. The time horizon of the analysis must therefore match the real horizon of the measure's consequences.
Finally, administrations need information systems capable of linking expenditure, activities, assets and results. Without that knowledge, the quality of an adjustment will remain largely a matter of political judgement. This is probably one of the most important limits of the approach: one can only manage precisely what one is able to see.
The limits of this grid
It would nonetheless be misleading to present this method as a universal answer. The boundary between productive and unproductive spending is rarely clear-cut. Social spending may appear as an operating cost while producing significant effects on human capital, health or social inclusion several years later.
Financial urgency poses a second limit. When a State faces a liquidity crisis or abruptly loses access to financing, it does not always have the time needed to select savings with precision. It must sometimes act before the ideal information is available.
Lastly, this grid presupposes a degree of maturity in budgetary and accounting systems. To distinguish what is saved from what is merely deferred, one still needs a sufficiently good understanding of the cost of public policies and their effects. These limits do not make the approach useless. They simply recall an essential reality of performance management: a good analytical framework never replaces judgement. It organises it.
Conclusion: cutting, while knowing what to protect
The budget balance will remain an indispensable indicator. No State can govern for long while ignoring its financial constraint. But the balance cannot, on its own, become the judge of the quality of fiscal policy. Between two consolidations of the same scale, the more sustainable is not necessarily the one that produced the most spectacular figure in the short term. It is the one that improved the accounts while preserving the capacities on which future public action depends.
That is why the decisive question may no longer be: “How much have we cut?” but rather: “What have we chosen to cut, what have we chosen to protect, and will we still be able to act once the effort is over?”
This way of looking at adjustment opens up a broader agenda for public sector management control: building an indicator capable of assessing not only the risk of financial imbalance, but also the risk of erosion of the capacity for public action. It would be another way of measuring sustainability. And probably a more useful way of managing it.
Sources and references
Main references and illustrative facts cited in the article.
Alberto Alesina, Carlo Favero and Francesco Giavazzi, Austerity: When It Works and When It Doesn't, Princeton University Press, 2019.
International Monetary Fund, work and frameworks on sovereign debt sustainability.
Oficina de Presupuesto del Congreso, Argentina, Análisis de la ejecución presupuestaria de la Administración Nacional, julio 2026.
Banco Central de Reserva del Perú, monetary policy decisions, 2026.
Bank of Mauritius, Monetary Policy Committee decisions, 2026.
DiagTraM newsletter
Receive our next insights
A preview with each new issue, straight to your inbox. Read the rest on the website.
Unsubscribe in one click. No excessive mailings, GDPR compliant.
Written by
Jimmy FÉLIX
Founder, DiagTraM, governance, finance and performance management advisory
The P.R.E.T. grid (Performance, Risk, Échéance or time horizon, Transparency) offers an analytical framework to assess the consistency of executive remuneration, in both the private and public sectors.