Skip to content
contact@diagtram.com France and international
Response within 48 working hours Public procurement area FR | EN
DiagTraM, governance and steering Book a meeting
Article, Public finance

Spending less or spending better: what public performance management really changes

Perspective, Public finance
≈3%global growth
projected for 2026
Source: IMF

When growth slows, every euro counts for more.

Public management is home to a persistent belief: that the size of a budget reflects the quality of a policy. The more money is spent on a school, a hospital or a road, the better the citizen is supposedly served. It is a reassuring intuition. Above all, it is an incomplete one. A budget is not a result. It is an intention expressed in figures. And between the intention and the result lies a vast space, often poorly lit, that we call steering, or performance management.

“A budget is not a result. It is an intention expressed in figures.”

This article is not a reaction to the news. It addresses a question that runs through every administration, in every country, whatever the economic cycle. The question simply becomes more visible when growth slows. When the IMF projects global growth of around 3% for 2026, fiscal room for manoeuvre narrows everywhere. Expansion can no longer be relied upon to absorb inefficiencies. Every euro has to be looked at squarely. Yet whether growth is strong or weak, the principle remains the same. Slower growth merely exposes the issue; it is not its cause.

What the quality of public spending really means

Let us begin by naming things precisely, for vague words produce vague policies.

The quality of public spending, as I define it, is not the absence of spending. Nor is it the cheapest spending. It is the capacity of a public euro to produce the intended effect on citizens' real lives, at the best possible cost, without compromising future sustainability. That sentence holds three requirements: a real effect, a controlled cost and a sustainable trajectory. Remove any one of the three and what remains is no longer quality. It is bookkeeping.

3CRITERIA
Spending quality at a glance
A real effectEach euro delivers the expected impact on citizens' lives.
A controlled costThe best possible ratio between resources and results.
A sustainable trajectoryWithout compromising future sustainability.

This definition has an uncomfortable consequence. Spending can be entirely lawful, voted in accordance with the rules, executed without fraud, and still be of poor quality. Regularity answers the question: are we entitled to spend? Quality answers a far harder one: were we right to spend in this way?

Public performance is not business performance

The word performance is a trap. Imported from the private sector, it carries connotations of profitability, margins and return on investment. Transposed unchanged into the public sector, it becomes misleading, because an administration does not pursue profit. It pursues impact.

Output

What it produces

Kilometres of road, hours of teaching, cases processed. Easy to measure.

Impact

What it changes

Accidents avoided, skills acquired, lives improved. Hard to measure, but this is the real target.

An administration can be highly productive and have no impact at all. It can build a great deal, train a great deal, process a great deal, and still miss its target. Measuring output is easy. Measuring impact is hard. That is precisely why so many public organisations measure output and call it performance.

The tradition of performance auditing, upheld in particular by the international standards of supreme audit institutions, sums up the requirement in three words, which I rephrase in my own way: spend frugally, spend skilfully, spend usefully. Frugality looks at the cost of resources. Skill looks at the ratio between resources and what they produce. Usefulness looks at the link between what is produced and the intended effect. A policy performs fully only when all three are aligned.

The three-question test

To make all of this operational, I propose a simple tool that any public manager can apply to any line of spending. I call it the three-question test.

The tool
The three-question test
1
Relevance
What exactly is this euro for? What real need does it address, beyond the budget heading?
2
Effectiveness
Does it produce the expected effect, and how do we know? This is the question of evidence.
3
Efficiency
Could the same effect have been achieved at lower cost, or a better effect at the same cost?

These three questions correspond to three disciplines: relevance, effectiveness and efficiency. They seem obvious. Yet most public decisions never clear all three. We stop at the first, sometimes at the second, rarely at the third. And it is the third that makes the difference between managing and steering.

Why steering so often fails

If the idea is so simple, why is it so rarely applied? Because steering runs up against three structural obstacles, which must be named if they are to be overcome.

The first is cultural. In many administrations, legitimacy is measured by the budget secured, not by the result delivered. A manager who spends their entire budget is seen as effective, when all they have done is consume it. As long as recognition goes to consumption rather than to results, steering will remain mere rhetoric.

The second is instrumental. You cannot steer what you do not measure, and measuring impact requires data, carefully chosen indicators and reliable information systems. Too many organisations are swamped with activity indicators and short of outcome indicators. They know everything about what they do, and almost nothing about what they change.

The third is temporal. The impact of a policy plays out over years, while budgetary and political cycles are counted in months. Steering demands a patience that the public calendar rarely allows. It is as much a problem of governing time as of management.

The interplay between the state and the rest of the economy

One final point deserves to be made, as it is often overlooked. The quality of public spending is not a matter internal to the administration. It flows through the entire economy. A state that spends poorly raises the cost of credit, increases the future tax burden and undermines the confidence of private actors. Conversely, a company that fails to invest in its own productivity weakens the tax base on which public spending rests. The two spheres are not separate. They are two sides of the same mountain. What is at stake in the quality of public spending is also the strength of the contract that binds the state to those who fund it.

Conclusion

Spending less is not a policy. Spending better is. The difference between the two lies in a word that is often spoken and seldom practised: steering. Steering is not about monitoring budget lines. It means constantly linking an intention, an execution and a result, then correcting course when any one of the three drifts. It is demanding work, often thankless, rarely spectacular. But it is the only work that turns a budget into a service delivered. In an environment where every euro counts for more, this skill ceases to be a specialist's luxury. It becomes the very heart of public service.


Sources and references

The concepts used in this article are rephrased in my own words. The sources below serve to attribute the original frameworks, not to reproduce their definitions.

  • Framework of the three requirements of public performance (economy, efficiency, effectiveness), drawn from the performance audit tradition of supreme audit institutions INTOSAI, ISSAI standards
  • Performance and results logic in central government budget management, rooted in France's Organic Law on Budget Acts Légifrance, LOLF
  • Public sector accounting standards and the requirement for financial transparency IPSAS Board, IFAC
  • Illustrative figure: global growth projected at around 3% for 2026 IMF, World Economic Outlook Update
DiagTraM Newsletter

Receive our latest insights

A preview of each new piece, straight to your inbox. You read the rest on our website.

Unsubscribe in one click. No unsolicited mailings, GDPR compliant.

Written by

Jimmy FÉLIX

Founder, DiagTraM, governance, finance and performance management advisory

All insights
TopicsPublic financePerformance management
Insights

Further reading

Let us take stock of your organisation

A first confidential conversation, with no commitment, to understand your challenges and identify the priority levers for action.